Powered by Bravenet Bravenet Blog

Subscribe to Journal

Wednesday, September 4th 2013

10:25 AM

Why So Serious?

"Why So Serious?"
-The Joker, "The Dark Knight"

Recently, a lady online who's observed a number of my interactions in one of the forums I'm a member of, gave her unsolicited opinion - and advice - that I should "smile" more (i.e., be more humorous); doing so, she asserted, would make my "message" go down a bit easier. 

Whether one agrees or not with that point of view, something occurred to me, actually several things:

1. That this wasn't the first time I'd heard such a thing

2. That all of the people who've said such a thing to me happened to be Women

3. That if the positions were reversed, I would probably be rightly upbraided for getting on a Woman's - in this case Sista's - case for "mean mugging". 

By now, surely you know what I'm talking about - there has been a goodly bit of pushback against the notion of Men "telling" Women to "smile" - many Women, Sistas included, rightly see this as a gendered imposition into their personal space and lives. After all, so many of them say, if the shoe were on the other foot, such a thing would *never* happen. 

Only problem is, I'm living proof, that it DOES. 

You see, I've had quite a few Women, in this case Sistas, "kindly suggest" (read: give their unsolicited opinion/advice) as to how I should "lighten up!", "interject some humor" into what I'm saying, etc - and in many ways, it is no different than the demands on the part of Brothas, for Women to "smile!" when out and about. 

In fact, I know for a fact, that the very same Women who make a stink out of the above situation, about them supposedly "mean mugging", have no qualms about turning around and demanding that I "smile!" for them and/or others, too.

There's a word for that, dontcha know. 

I won't deign to speak for the Sistahood as to how and why they think not smiling is a good thing - besides, we all know they are more than capable of speaking for themselves - instead, I'll give my take on how and why I don't see it as particularly beneficial for me to attempt to ape Kevin Hart or Eddie Murphy.


Because, to be frank, there are far too many Brothas who attempt to be "funny" as it is - and far too few Brothas, who are serious about ANYTHING. And I like the idea of being seen and regarded, as a Serious Brotha. 

Indeed, in what can rightly be called the Black Internet, the vast majority of Black male participants, and that includes the relatively few Brotha bloggers, seem to bend over backwards, in a Will Smith during his Fresh Prince of Bel-Air days kind of way, to be "funny" and "humorous" - and for the vast majority of them, I am sorry, it just doesn't work. They make themselves look like a Fool, even moreso when considering the reason why they do so (which I've addressed recently). Women of substance can and will appreciate a Brotha who uses his head for something more than a place to hang his fedora, and won't need for him to try to crack corny jokes that aren't funny, just so he can show "another side of himself". The very thought, the idea, is as demeaning as when any Man demands that a Woman they don't even know(!) "smile!", like they're Mr. Rourke on Fantasy Island or something. 

So, no - not only don't I "smile", I actually find it insulting for Women to "suggest" it to me, for all the reasons above, but especially because they wouldn't appreciate it if a Man said the same to them while they were going about their business. Black America needs more Brothas who take life just a weebit more seriously than a standup comic. 

Oh, and one more thing, ladies: 

If a Brotha is desirous of your opinion, or "advice", he will be keen to ask you for it. 

Now adjourn your arses...

The Obsidian
17 comment(s).

Posted by B.P.:

Similar to the story of my life--and not just with sistas. I get that generally women don't know what to make of a "serious," together-looking brotha, especially one who isn't on any pious religious or ideological trip.

But sistas often seem offended or put-upon when dealing with a thoughtful, composed brotha who shows no interest in catering, pedestalizing, or even getting in their good graces. This despite all the complaining about the undersupply of suitably qualified black men.

I've learned to be indifferent to gender with women who don't first display some interest in me. This works well enough in everyday space--but not nearly as well online, especially when sistas are around. Clearly, they aren't accustomed to being "talked back" to, straight and intelligently, by black men.
Wednesday, September 4th 2013 @ 4:19 PM

Posted by Obsidian:

You make a really good point that I've been meaning to get to for some time, and hopefully I will, very soon - stay tuned!

Wednesday, September 4th 2013 @ 7:57 PM

Posted by Marc W. Polite:

Kudos on this post Obsidian. I am not a "smiler" myself either, so I understand where you are coming from with this.
Thursday, September 5th 2013 @ 9:59 AM

Posted by Obsidian:

Thanks, Man! I'll have more to say on this topic soon, because it *is* important to have a sense of humor, but there's a way guys like us should go about it...stay tuned...

Thursday, September 5th 2013 @ 10:43 AM

Posted by Bahrain web design company:

Thanks for sharing these wonderful designs, its helpful to all.
Friday, September 6th 2013 @ 4:00 AM

Posted by Obat Herbal Epilepsi:

Pernah DengarBlog Kuherbal yang merupakan blog untuk Kesehatan dan telah menjual suatu Obat Obat yang menjadi suatulegenda atau Karya 2013 dan akan menjadi cetar atau memebahana dneganKuherbal Obat sekian hari ini

Mungkin sekarang waktunya dunia online semua hanya dnegan dunia maya sampai artikel dengan Manfaat Tumbuhan Obat Alami dengan cara apapun teet herbal dan Kuobatmempunyai khasiat untuk mengobati Sakit Obat seperti epilepsi dan jantung atau mioma,kista karya gen99 dan MY dnegan deasain dan bantuan karya blog Blog Edu terjadi karena dan Cuma Aku
Friday, September 6th 2013 @ 10:21 AM

Posted by Tas Online Murah dari Batam:

Its hard to find knowledgeable people on this topic
Friday, December 6th 2013 @ 7:49 AM

Posted by obat herbal hiv aids:

Thank you so much for all the info, greetings successful yah gan ..
Monday, February 3rd 2014 @ 1:27 AM

Posted by LUKISAN:

www.ChoirunSholeh.com Perjuangan bukanlah sia-sia. Tekad dan harapan yang besar salah satu faktor yang membentuknya menjadi seorang pelukis yang cukup dikenal. Dan ini semua dicapai karena kemudahan dari Allah semata.www.choirunsholeh.com/contact
Wednesday, March 12th 2014 @ 3:14 AM

Posted by Jual Fly Ash:

FL ASH Penambah Daya Rekat Buat Semen.
Friday, March 14th 2014 @ 3:21 AM

Posted by obat herbal alergi:

Thank you so much for all the info, greetings successful yah gan ..
Monday, March 24th 2014 @ 3:30 AM

Posted by Obat Asam Lambung:

terimakasihh,,, info nya sangat bagus,,
Friday, March 28th 2014 @ 4:50 AM

Posted by obat herbal alergi:

Terima kasih banyak atas segala infonya..
Sunday, April 13th 2014 @ 9:45 PM

Posted by nurhuda.furqon:

Posted by obat herbal maag kronis:

terima kasih pak.. http://goo.gl/I1FycS kami agen distributor obat herbal Terpercaya yang secara online,
terima kasih atas semua info yang telah diberikan, sangat membantu kami mendapatkan informasi yang akurat dan sangat menarik ini;
dan yg pasti berguna bagi semua masyarakat yang membacanya..terus semangat,kami tunggu info selanjutnya
Wednesday, May 14th 2014 @ 10:45 PM

Posted by johnpatinson:

I just thought it may be an idea to post incase anyone else was having problems researching but I am a little unsure if I am allowed to put names and addresses on here.
cpa marketing forum
Wednesday, May 21st 2014 @ 2:48 AM

Posted by Harga LG L70 Dual:

This is good content thank you for adding it here.
Saturday, May 24th 2014 @ 4:09 PM